46) Jon Richard Reuter: Elected mayor for the City of Welland in 1991, 1994 & 1997
Vital statistics
Birth: February 17, 1945 at Welland, Ontario, Canada
Parents: William Joseph / Madeline
Spouse: Bona
Children: Jeffrey / Gregory / Brian / Joann
Occupation: Insurance Broker
Profile
Jon Richard Reuter was born on February 17, 1945 in Welland to William Joseph and Madeline Reuter. William Joseph, his father, was a lifelong resident of Welland and never lived more than a half-mile from his childhood home on the corner of Aqueduct St. and Thorold Rd. His father began his career at Page-Hersey and then formed multiple business enterprises, such as Pinecroft Dairy and also Seaway Plate and Structural Steel. He also served many times on Thorold Township council, with one term as deputy reeve, auguring his son Jon’s civic career. In 1992 Jon (hereafter referred to as Dick as he was most well-known as) spoke of his father: “He prided himself in the fact that he had always been true to himself, and that he didn’t have an enemy in the city of Welland… I guess that’s a pretty good thing to be able to say.”
Dick was educated at Notre Dame College School in Welland. He was involved in many activities there; he played halfback on their football team, was a member of the school curling team, and worked on the yearbook committee. After graduating and encouraged by his father, he decided to enter the business world right away instead of pursuing a university education. He first worked for an acceptance company in Sarnia, then moved out to British Columbia for another job. His company transferred him back to Niagara, and he eventually built his own successful insurance brokerage, which he sold in 1988. That year he was forty-three years old, and he said his reasons for selling his business was that he was tired after working very hard, the offer was attractive, and he had a desire to do other things.
In 1988 he began volunteering with the Community Futures Committee, acting as chairman, in an effort to “pull Welland out from its federal designation as an economically disadvantaged community.” Reuter said “Our portfolio has been very successful… I’d like to think we have just a first rate, top notch business development centre in the city.” The mayor Roland Hardy appointed Dick to a task force on social-economic development in 1990.
In 1991, Dick says he was approached by several people telling him to run for mayor (the incumbent mayor Roland Hardy had by this time expressed publicly that he was not seeking re-election). Dick's first reaction was that he didn’t feel like a politician, and it wasn’t the type of thing he necessarily wanted to do. Those supporters were persistent and he changed his mind. “I really thought there was an opportunity to make a difference – to really do something.”
On November 12, 1991 he was elected mayor, with the votes as such: Dick Reuter - 4,415, George Marshall - 4,231, Patsy J. Mollica - 3,574, Susan Noyes - 3,394, Frank A. Zimmer - 2,274 and Phil Bradley - 754. It was called a dramatic election in the newspaper, as he was a newcomer who beat out four experienced councillors and a former council candidate, and it also featured a tight finish. One of his campaign promises was to freeze the mayor’s salary and donate $10,000 of it back to the city to create jobs, which is a promise he kept. “I’ll never go back on my word on any of my campaign promises… I believe people in Welland wanted a business approach to running government. We ran our campaign with the idea of a new image and I think that was accepted.”
He was re-elected in 1994 and then for a third time in 1997, both dominant victories with about 70% of the vote share. As reasons for his success Reuter cited the city acquisition of the former canal lands, getting a long-term lease for the courthouse, and new business developments such as Zehrs and Business Depot. He also said the strong election results meant “a mandate by the city. It tells me to go on and keep going in the same direction I have been going in.”
Reuter was mayor for most of the 1990s, yet he was not tired of the job and ran for mayor again in 2000 and 2003, however there was a marked change in how voters perceived him by these elections. On November 13, 2000 he lost to Cindy Forster, who became the first female mayor of Welland. The votes were strongly in her favour: Cindy Forster - 15,806, Jon Reuter - 4,593, John Watt – 338, and Charlie McIntyre – 174. He didn’t fare much better in the 2003 election in which he came fourth place: Damian Goulborne - 7,554, Cindy Forster - 5,312, Philip Bradley - 2,036, Jon Reuter - 1,892, John Watt – 473, and Frank Garofalo – 378.
Dick didn’t expect the reversal of fortune. When he was campaigning for the 2000 election he said “We’ve had more achievements in the past nine years than in the previous 40 and I’ve been here to witness it. I think that is my strength to push ahead and make things happen. Being the mayor, in my view, is not just filling pot holes and fixing sidewalks it’s a whole lot more. It’s having a vision for the community and trying to lead the city in prosperity and create jobs for our kids.” So what was the cause for his loss of support? A downtown civic centre project he had been spearheading since 1991. The current building at 60 East Main Street that houses Welland City Hall and the Welland Public Library and which was opened in 2005 is the result of that vision. At various times it could have been a combination of city hall, library, YMCA, commercial tenants, and the police services board. However many disagreed with how he went about making it happen. Cindy Forster who won the election in dominant fashion said in her campaign: “I am completely opposed to the current civic centre project. It is ill conceived and I cannot believe we are building a structure without knowing exactly what we are building or what the final costs are. Since we now have a hole in the middle of our downtown, something has to be put there. I think we should seek further public consultation where all citizens have an opportunity to participate rather than hiring expensive consultants.” Reuter said that it had already received much public input and was being funded from reserves, other levels of government, and the private sector. He said it was good planning and it was being built without increasing taxes, and would ultimately be a catalyst for reviving downtown.
An editorial after the election explained that Reuter couldn’t sell the concept to his council or to most voters. The council kept getting split down the middle, and many incumbent councillors lost the election in addition to Dick. “In order to pull off a project of this magnitude, it’s vitally important for a municipal council to speak with one voice. This one never came close to accomplishing that. As a result, Reuter was perceived as politically arrogant, out of touch with “the people.”” The editorial went on to say there was a fine line between leadership and autocracy and Reuter straddled that line often, whether he meant to or not. After the election Reuter said “There is a massive amount of support for Coun. Forster. Obviously, the new council will have to take the (civic centre) project back to square one.” He also said he was proud of his record and respected the voters decision.
As mentioned, he ran again in 2003: he thought council was spending foolishly, with property taxes increasing, businesses leaving, and council was infighting rendering it ineffective. Voters did want change, but opted instead for newcomer Damian Goulbourne as mayor. This was the last time Dick ran for public office.
Sources
- “Backlash.” The Tribune, November 14, 2000.
- “Dick Reuter has a lot to say about our Futures.” The Tribune, March 30, 1991.
- “Dick Reuter: Man of the ‘real’ people.” The Tribune, March 24, 1992.
- “Mayor’s father dies at 98.” The Tribune, October 2, 2000.
- “Reuter easily wins re-election.” The Tribune, November 11, 1997.
- “Reuter encourages students to get involved in government.” The Tribune, November 14, 2000.
- “Reuter raps spending, taxes in bid for mayor.” The Tribune, September 30, 2003.
- “Reuter wins it.” The Tribune, November 13, 1991.
- “Stunning result surprises Reuter.” The Tribune, November 14, 2000.
- “The Tribune asks the candidates…” The Tribune, October 28, 2000.
